Content Section

Romney's Puzzling Math

139593703JS006_ROMNEY_HOLDS

Republican presidential hopeful and former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney speaks during a campaign rally at the Tri-City Christian Academy on February 22, 2012 in Chandler, Arizona (Justin Sullivan / Getty Images)

Here's what I don't get.

Mitt Romney claims that his new proposal to reduce the top rate of federal personal income tax to 28% will not benefit the top 1%.

I’m going to limit the deductions and exemptions particularly for the higher-income folks. For high-income folks, we’re going to cut back on that, so that we ensure that the top 1 percent keeps paying the current share they’re paying and more.

How does the math on this remotely work?

Yes, I can imagine that a scale-back in the deductions for state and local taxes or mortgage interest might conceivably balance the value of the tax cut for a family at the lower edge of the top 1%. But what possible change in the deduction schedule could offset the value of a 7 point tax cut for somebody earning more than $1 million, much less more than $10 million?

You Might Also Like

Comments

About

Author headshot

David Frum

David Frum is a contributing editor at Newsweek and The Daily Beast and a CNN contributor. He is the author of seven books, including most recently, his first novel Patriots published in April 2012.

David's Book Club

From The Daily Beast

Mary 'Depressed' by RFK Split

Mary 'Depressed' by RFK Split

RFK Jr.’s wife battled drug and alcohol problems and was depressed that her marriage could not be reconciled, friends tell Eleanor Clift.

No Worries

Don’t Fear the FBI, JPMorgan

No Choice

Mitt’s Tea-Party Masters

Prohibitionist for President?

5 Fringe White House Hopefuls

Quirk Overload?

Wes Anderson Divides Cannes

FrumForum Archive

Closing Arguments, But the Saga’s Not Over

The verdict watch begins! Closing arguments ended at John Edwards’s trial and Newsweek & The Daily Beast’s Diane Dimond reports that the arguments waged by the defense and prosecution couldn’t have been more different.

  1. Did We Underestimate Bashar al-Assad? Play

    Did We Underestimate Bashar al-Assad?

  2. Would You Get Rid of Nuclear Weapons? Play

    Would You Get Rid of Nuclear Weapons?

  3. Romney Advisor: Jeremiah Wright Ad Not in Our Control Play

    Romney Advisor: Jeremiah Wright Ad Not in Our Control